• Learn more about us:

Menu Close
The bigger picture

The weather-headache nexus

name. With so many people reporting that changes in the weather trigger a migraine or tension-type headache attack, the headache-weather link is a perennial topic of interest. In some studies, as many as 70 percent of subjects report a causal link between weather conditions and their headaches. So no wonder numerous studies have set out to establish once and for all whether there are significant associations between weather and headache, and, best case, identify definite correlations that would explain them.

Research theory and practice

Many of these studies are designed the same way. People with migraine or tension-type headache record the details of their attacks in a headache diary over a specific period of time. Over that same period, researchers keep track of weather data (air pressure, temperature, humidity, wind movement, etc.) sourced in most cases from the nearest weather station. The researchers also record dynamic processes such as drops in atmospheric pressure and rising temperatures, since a lot of people link their attacks to changes in the weather. A tremendous amount of data is collected in this way.

Then, using mathematical and statistical models, patient headache diary records are compared to specific local weather parameters at those times and combinations thereof (e.g., atmospheric pressure and temperature). The purpose of all this number crunching is to discover any statistically significant, robust correlations between certain combinations of weather phenomena and headache events.

So much for the theory, based on which you would expect similar procedures to produce comparable results. In practice, the results turn out to be remarkably heterogeneous. Some studies see no relation at all. Others identify minor correlations at best. In any event, the science in this field is remarkably inconsistent compared to hard science research in other areas. Still, let’s have a brief look at some of the studies.

Some study results

A study at Charité hospital in Berlin cross-checked the headache diaries of migraineurs against weather data including 4-hourly temperature and atmospheric pressure (barometric) data over a period of one year. In six patients, a statistically significant correlation was found between migraine attacks and weather phenomena; specifically, a drop in temperature with a simultaneous increase in humidity. No other correlations were detected.

Genetics, the "silent" factor

In their discussion of the results, the authors consider whether genetic confounders might play a role. Are there individuals in the study population whose genetics make them more sensitive to patterns or changes in the weather, the authors ask. That would explain why significant correlations were found in just one subset. Nonetheless, the study reveals how difficult it is to say anything for sure when factors such as the subject's current state of mind, genetic predisposition, and physically measurable weather data are all in play at the same time.

The authors cautiously propose that there may indeed be a sub-population of migraine patients whose genetics make them more reactive to weather phenomena than the rest of the population. This would also neatly explain the striking inconsistency between different – but similarly designed – studies. Ignoring genetics when selecting subjects might give rise, quite by chance, to groups with wildly different or identical genetics, and these unknown factors would affect the results of the research.

Inconsistent evidence

A University of Vienna in 238 migraineurs asked participants to keep a diary for 90 days and enter details on 59 items on each of those days, including subjective weather perceptions. Upon statistical analysis, it first seemed that there were some correlations. After multivariate analysis (correction for multiple testing), the findings were no longer significant. This is another example of a very common phenomenon in research. A very large proportion of patients will be absolutely clear in their own minds that (a change in) the weather gives them a headache. But at the end of the day, these are subjective perceptions that rarely stand up to scientific scrutiny.

As already stated, the evidence is inconsistent and there is always another study that says the exact opposite. In 2011, Kazuhito Kimoto at Dokkyo Medical University in Mibu, Japan, published a study in migraineurs confirming a link between migraine attacks and barometric pressure. Static pressure did not have an effect. Instead, migraine attacks occurred more frequently – in 18 of 28 patients studied – when barometric pressure was more than 5 hPa lower from one day to the next.

Discrepancy between what people sense and what the data shows

Research by Prince, Rapoport et al at Yale University School of Medicine in Connecticut, USA, also found a statistical correlation between one or more weather phenomena and migraine occurrence in some subjects. However, far more subjects thought they were sensitive than were actually found to be sensitive to weather. In addition, factors other than self-reported triggers were found to have an effect. So there was a clear but ultimately unexplained discrepancy between perceived connections and demonstrable correlation.

So what is the truth?

Few areas of research produce a more mixed bag of results and contentious claims than the headache-weather connection. If you believe science can shed reliable light on what’s going on here, think again. There are too many variables involved and everyone’s subjective perceptions are different. Without a doubt, our bodies react to the weather. And some people are more sensitive to a change in weather than others. But that’s about all anybody can say for sure.

Sensitivity to the weather may also be partly due to the fact that our bodies are out of practice and no longer able to respond fast enough to different weather conditions, or (more importantly) in the proper physiological manner using the right physical processes – to quote Angela Schuh, a professor of medical climatology at Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität (LMU) Munich in her book “Biowetter” [“Bioweather”]. The author also points out that most people these days work indoors, get too little daylight and lead irregular lives. This "de-rhythmization," as Schuh calls it, might also play its part in causing headaches associated with weather sensitivity. Which brings us back to the conclusion that a multifactorial process is involved that largely eludes elucidation with the tools of natural science.



  • 1. Hoffmann J, Lo H, Neeb L, Martus P, Reuter U. Weather sensitivity in migraineurs. J Neurol. 2011 Apr;258(4):596-602. doi: 10.1007/s00415-010-5798-7. Epub 2010 Oct 24.


    2. Holzhammer J, Wöber C. Nichtalimentäre Triggerfaktoren bei Migräne und Kopfschmerz vom Spannungstyp. Schmerz. 2006 Jun;20(3):226-37. Review.


    3. Kimoto K, Aiba S, Takashima R, Suzuki K, Takekawa H, Watanabe Y, Tatsumoto M, Hirata K. Influence of barometric pressure in patients with migraine headache. Intern Med. 2011;50(18):1923-8. Epub 2011 Sep 15.


    4. Prince PB, Rapoport AM, Sheftell FD, Tepper SJ, Bigal ME. The effect of weather on headache. Headache. 2004 Jun;44(6):596-602.


    5. Schuh A: Biowetter. München 2007.


    6. Wöber C. Was sind echte Kopfschmerztrigger? MMW Fortschr Med. 2012 Feb 9;154(2):65-7.


    7. Zebenholzer K, Rudel E, Frantal S, Brannath W, Schmidt K, Wöber-Bingöl C, Wöber C. Migraine and weather: a prospective diary-based analysis. Cephalalgia. 2011 Mar;31(4):391-400. doi: 10.1177/0333102410385580.


    8. Internet: https/www.welt.de/gesundheit/article146248875/Kann-das-Wetter-Migraene-Attacken-ausloesen.html

    close

Zurück

NOCH MEHR:

LATEST
ARTICLES

DIE NEUSTEN
INFORMATIONEN

Deep Dive

Headaches affect almost everyone. With their widespread prevalence comes a remarkable array of myths surrounding their causes. Let’s delve into some “classic” headache myths and see if there’s any

Deep Dive

Headaches affect almost everyone. With their widespread prevalence comes a remarkable array of myths surrounding their causes. Let’s delve into some “classic” headache myths and see if there’s any

The bigger picture

Presenteeism in the narrower sense used in this article means when employees show up for work despite being ill. How widespread is this phenomenon? Why do people choose work over rest and recovery?

The bigger picture

Many people believe their headaches are directly related to the weather. We explored the connections in a previous article. The verdict: the science so far has not uncovered any mechanisms that would

Deep Dive

Developed by American doctor and psychologist Edmund Jacobson, progressive muscle relaxation (PMR) is a valuable tool for headache sufferers. As described previously in this article, numerous studies

Deep Dive

How do migraine headaches feel? Are they the same for everyone affected by them? How severe is my pain and how much does it limit me?

People who want to measure pain are faced with a significant

Headaches as a symptom of long COVID

“The coronavirus pandemic is over!” As these words were pronounced a good two years after the outbreak of a hitherto unknown viral infection, which had the whole world paralysed for a long time, there

DEEP DIVE

The medication-overuse headache (referred to hereafter as MOH) has been well-known for a relatively long time. It was first described as an independent phenomenon in 1951. According to its definition,

PREVENTION IN PRACTICE

Studying was badly affected by the coronavirus crisis. Many new students were caught unawares by the suspension of in-person events and could not enjoy lectures and classes in a familiar environment

Prevention in Practice

For many of us, the summer holidays are the best time of year. We have put together several tips in this article on how to achieve real relaxation – regardless of whether you want to take some time

DEEP DIVE

The fact that stress is a key factor in the development of migraine attacks is undisputed and repeatedly backed up by research. In practice, it is clear that people with migraine who succeed in

THE BIGGER PICTURE

Our genes are subject to the laws of evolution. Since the beginnings of humanity, they have undergone constant change, and still do to this day. We know that the course of evolution intends for traits

The bigger picture

We all know about pain. Pain is an important mode of communication between us and our organism. Contrary to what has long been assumed, it seems that there are differences between men and women when

DEEP DIVE

In our last article, we presented several explanatory approaches to the connection between blood pressure and headaches. In this continuation, we will be explaining a further, much-discussed

DEEP DIVE

The question of how headaches and high blood pressure relate to each other has a long tradition in medical research. Even today, the results in this field are very inconsistent and continue to give

Living with Tension-Type Headache

If you sleep badly, you have a higher risk of getting headaches. At the same time, headaches often bring about sleeping problems. It is undisputed that both headaches and bad sleep influence each

The bigger picture

The World Health Organisation (WHO) counts migraine as one of the most severely disabling illnesses affecting humanity; in general, headache disorders are a great burden to those affected by them. In

PREVENTION IN PRACTICE

Stress is an undisputed factor in the development of headaches and migraine. Relaxing and calming measures are important pillars of migraine and headache prevention, and current research supports this

DEEP DIVE

The fact that wearing face masks can effectively prevent getting infected with the coronavirus, is now adequately proven. Covid face masks therefore belong to the repertoire of measures we are

DEEP DIVE

Migraine is a neurological disorder that affects millions of people worldwide. Centuries-worth of research into this complex clinical entity is continuing to give birth to new hypotheses. The last few

The bigger picture

The World Health Organization (WHO) ranks migraine among the world’s most disabling illnesses. Yet migraine stigma persists. Many people are skeptical about migraine and other headache disorders,

Prevention in Practice

Holistic management of migraine and other types of headache now offers a treatment arsenal that is about much more than medication alone. In fact, it embraces many elements of behavioral therapy.

The bigger picture

In a world full of sensory overload, silence is something many people only know from hearsay. This article looks at why unplugging from environmental noise is good medicine for headaches and migraine

Prevention in Practice

The classic advice from experts in headache prevention is to drink regularly. Boozing every night? Well, no. They mean staying hydrated and giving your body the fluids it needs. Specialists recommend

DEEP DIVE

The brains of people with migraine have a special way of processing sensory input. Headache research suggests that a migraine brain responds to incoming stimuli sooner and faster than a non-migraine

Living with Migraine

The diet-headache connection is one of the hottest of topics for patients and experts alike. Migraine sufferers often see a direct link between how and what they eat and a migraine attack. This

Give yourself a break

Studies show that headache disorders take a heavy toll on student productivity and performance. Nearly one in three sufferers reported 'severe disability' (the highest severity level) using the MIDAS

The bigger picture

Humans are hard-wired to follow a routine. Your natural 24-hour cycle (circadian rhythm) governs many of the physiological processes in your body, including brain activity, blood pressure, hormones

DEEP DIVE

Paradoxical but true: medications you take for headache relief can themselves trigger headaches. A nervous system control mechanism is behind this phenomenon. Taking painkillers regularly and for a

Living with Migraine

Many people with a migraine will try to get out of the light. Often they have no choice but to go into a dark room and wait for the attack to end. Increased sensitivity to light is common in people

Current Research

All the statistics show that migraine affects women more than men, but experts disagree on what causes this gender gap. The role of sex hormones as migraine triggers is a hot research topic these

Digital stress and its consequences

Digital stress (or technostress) is a burgeoning area of interest in medical and social science research. How does it affect us to be surrounded by digital media in almost every area of our lives?

Prevention in Practice

Congratulations, you made it through another digital semester of online lectures, studying alone on your laptop, the final push to pass your exams. Semester break is here and you so deserve it. As the

Prevention in Practice

Where would we be without our smartphones? Life these days is hard to imagine without a phone to plan the day, find information we need right this second, keep up with hobbies or just to pass the

The bigger picture

Rarely has a saying been more apt than now. Covid is a headache on so many levels. The contact restrictions are causing profound distress. Fear and uncertainty are everywhere. Will it ever go away?

The bigger picture

Do short, gray, sunless winter days get you down? You’re not alone. The science is clear: daylight-deprived winter days affect our mood. Our hunter-gatherer ancestors would say it’s time to retreat

Current Research

Everyone has a different noise tolerance level. One person’s “barely noticeable” is another’s “unbearable”. Many people find it especially hard to be around those everyday sounds we hear all the time.

Prevention in Practice

The most strenuous events are not usually distributed evenly across the week. Monday mornings (that notorious 8. a.m. lecture...) can frazzle your nerves and set the week off to a highly stressful

DEEP DIVE

Vertigo (spinning dizziness) in migraine has only recently gained traction as a research topic. The science on migraine-related vertigo is unclear. One study found that only 10% of people are

Current Research

Coffee ranks high on the headache triggers list. The ingredient that gives you the buzz – caffeine – is one of the best-loved psychostimulants (uppers) ever. As a pick-me-up at work or just to hang

Prevention in Practice

In a 2018 study by Turner and Houle, headache patients were asked what factors commonly trigger their pain. Three-quarters said stress was the main trigger, closely followed by "irregular meals" and

The bigger picture

Teeth grinding (bruxism) has been commonly linked to headache. Bruxism is not a niche phenomenon. One in five female college students and one-tenth of their male peers are aware that they clench or

The bigger picture

The exercise-headache connection continues to vex scientists. Conducting genuine evidence-based science is hard because, first, the research conditions are difficult to standardize; second, many of

Living with Migraine

Migraine is not an allergic disorder, but migraine is more common in people with allergies. Doctors noticed the link more than a century ago. Individual case reports dating mainly from the first half

The bigger picture

The "HEADACHE HURTS" campaign taught us that (especially if you have migraine) about 7 hours of regular, undisturbed sleep is a great way to stop horrible headache attacks or at least not provoke them

Prevention in Practice

Headaches make it harder to think, reason and remember – so when you need to be on top of your game, pampering your brain is crucial. Proactive headache prevention is essential, because you need to be

DEEP DIVE

Your brain produces large amounts of waste products (cellular detritus; remnants of dead cells, proteins and much more) that need to be cleared away to keep your brain healthy.

One example of harmful

Prevention in Practice

Careful nutrition can help prevent headaches. But careful nutrition doesn’t just mean what you eat, but when and how. Migraine patients benefit from a regular daily routine that is less likely to

DEEP DIVE

The term “stress” as used today was coined by Hans Selye, a Hungarian-Canadian clinician who defined it as "the non-specific response of the body to any demand for change". Selye once called stress